Melody, against the grain, went shopping in Muggle London for her family's presents, getting various knick-knacks she thought her family members might like (Xander got a muggle nutcracker doll, for example).

Siobhan apparently knits and made each of her family members (including her brother-in-law Victor) something unique to each of them; a pair of gloves with a slight waterproofing enchantment for Elijah, a scarf for Vincent, a blanket for Gabrielle, a sweater for Josiah, and socks for Victor.

Beyond her unplayed family, the only person Toni would have given a present to (currently) is her Pendergast roommate, Elise. The present wasn't a secret between the pair of them — the end result was. Toni had Elise sit for a portrait, which she had framed and slightly altered (using current photo-manipulation techniques such as painting) to be ~extremely fashionable~