Benevolence couldn't help but feel inwardly perturbed by Charley's dismissal of education and lessons. As a former Ravenclaw, Benevolence had always valued knowledge and the pursuit of learning. She firmly believed that education was never a waste of time and that every individual deserved the opportunity to develop their abilities and talents.

However, Benevolence's concern deepened when Charley mentioned her father's view on teaching her magic. She could sense the young girl's resignation and self-doubt, and it tugged at her. Benevolence bit her lip hard, struggling to find the right words to impart her belief in the importance of education.

Then, Charley mentioned her struggle with imagination and her father's absence when she tried to 'magin him.' Benevolence's heart sank as she thought about the pain and longing that the young girl must feel. She knew what it was like to miss her parents, having lost her own father at a young age, her mother years before that. While her situation had been gentler than Charley's, there was no shortage of help for well bred and wealthy young ladies, the pain of losing loved ones was something they both shared.

"When did you lose your mama and papa?" Benevolence asked, choosing her words carefully to show empathy and understanding. As she waited for Charley's response, Benevolence's mind raced with thoughts of how she could support and guide the young girl. She knew that her own experiences as an orphan had shaped her perspective and had driven her to create a successful life for herself. She wanted to find a way to impart some of that resilience and hope to Charley, to let her know that she was not alone and that there was a path forward, even in the face of challenges.

In the meantime, Benevolence refilled Charley's teacup, almost as a response, providing a moment of warmth and comfort in the midst of their conversation. She offered a soft smile, trying to convey her sincerity and genuine care for the young girl.