Updates
Welcome to Charming
Welcome to Charming, the year is now 1894. It’s time to join us and immerse yourself in scandal and drama interlaced with magic both light and dark.

Where will you fall?

Featured Stamp

Add it to your collection...

Did You Know?
Did you know? Jewelry of jet was the haute jewelry of the Victorian era. — Fallin
What she got was the opposite of what she wanted, also known as the subtitle to her marriage.
all dolled up with you


Private
all & then most of you, some & now none of you
#1
January 24th, 1891 — Crouch Home, Swallowbury

Ben had never been an organized person. He could usually find things in a minute or two, when he needed them, and even when he couldn't it hadn't ever been the end of the world, so he saw no need to change his ways now. Letters were sorted vaguely into piles of things he needed to deal with, things he ought to give to someone at the main office to file, personal things, things that had been resolved, things that he could just as easily have thrown in the trash but had instead left in a pile. They were all messy piles, there was some overlap between them, but there was a system of sorts. So when he'd gone into his office that morning and seen things had been moved, he'd known immediately that something had happened. When he took a look at the desk more clearly and realized what papers happened to be on top, he knew exactly what. He'd taken care not to leave anything that mentioned Elliot out where it could be easily found, yet here they all were, right on top. The housekeeper wouldn't have touched anything on his desk; she'd long since given up on trying to tidy his work things. Melody must have found them, and in order to do that, she must have gone looking.

For a long while after he'd made the discover he simply sat in his desk chair, trying to figure out what might happen next. Melody was not going to take this well, but it was too late to do anything about it. He should have burned the letters as he'd received them, if he was being honest. He could have burned them now, but even after they'd been discovered he couldn't bring himself to destroy the only descriptions he had of his son. At least he'd had the most recent letter still tucked into his breast pocket when he'd gone out last night. That was the only one that had his name on it, which meant Melody wouldn't have had the information she needed to piece together his identity, or his mother's.

It did mean that he likely couldn't write to her for the foreseeable future, though. Melody didn't trust him, so she might go snooping again. She was intelligent, so she might figure it out. She was desperate, so she might even get someone else involved in order to figure it out.

This was bad.

He got nothing done that morning; just fretted aimlessly. He started a letter to Art, but couldn't decide what to say. He intentionally spilled ink on the half-written letter before throwing it in the trash, so that if Melody went snooping in his waste basket she wouldn't catch on to anything. He considered trying to ask Aldous for advice, but where would he even start? There was too much context here that Aldous was missing, and it would have taken him hours just to get his brother on the same page — during which time he would probably have a heart attack and die, Ben thought miserably.

When it was time for lunch he went down to the table, wondering if Melody would join him. It was possible she might have locked herself up in her room, expecting an apology. It was possible she had already gone off to the solicitor to seek a divorce.



MJ made this <3
#2
Melody remained in bed with the blanket pulled high over her head long after she knew breakfast to served. Any hunger she felt from missing both supper and breakfast was suppressed by the nausea that plagued her since her discovery. Or was it before? She didn't quite remember but it made no difference either way.

Ben had a son.

Ben had a son and he hadn't told her.

The thought repeated constantly throughout the night, causing fearful dreams that eventually left her too restless to sleep. In some ways, this revelation was even worse than him wanting a divorce. Especially if he wanted a relationship with his son, which, knowing Ben, he would. A relationship with his son meant having a relationship with his son's mother, and where did that leave her? The scorned, bitter wife who he never wanted anyway? Merlin, maybe they were better off separating. Maybe it was the only way she had a chance of securing happiness, too.

Melody thought about skipping lunch as well. Truthfully, she wasn't the least bit hungry and the thought of having to smell whatever Cook prepared for them was enough to make her reach for the bin once more. But, if she didn't go downstairs Ben would likely come looking, and Melody refused to have any further serious conversations with him anywhere other than neutral ground.

She didn't bother dressing in anything particularly nice for the day. Instead, she discarded her typical layers and the corset and dressed in just a basic dress. Melody wasn't planning on leaving the house, nor did she believe Cook would gossip about her state with all the tips she'd left her out of her allowance. Ben could deal with seeing her in such a state for once in their marriage. More than anything else, Melody, too, was tired of pretending.

Ben was already seated at the table when she entered and took up her typical spot across from him. But she offered no greeting nor did she look up at him. Melody hadn't the slightest idea where to even start this conversation.


[Image: dqAG6wz.png]
beautiful set by mj
#3
Ben found himself staring at her as she entered and sat, for a number of reasons. It was striking to him that she looked so different than she usually did; it was almost as though she'd wandered in wearing only her nightgown. She looked a mess — not planning to skip off to the solicitor today, then. He tried to decipher the look on her face but she wasn't giving him much to work with; she was just... blank. He wouldn't have known where to start trying to figure out what she was thinking. Was she hoping he would say something? If so, he had no idea what. There wasn't anything he wanted to say, and anything that came to mind as a possibility seemed too volatile. Maybe that was just everything, though. Maybe they were headed for a fight and there was no way to avoid it.

She sat, and Ben wondered if she was even going to say anything at all. Surely she must have known that he knew what she'd been up to. She couldn't just pretend nothing had happened (and she clearly wasn't pretending to be alright, given the state of her hair and dress).

He reached down and rubbed his thumb against the base of the soup spoon, causing it to rock slightly against the surface of the table. He hadn't picked up any of his utensils, yet, and hadn't taken a bite. He wasn't sure he would. Melody didn't look like she had any interest in eating, either.

She had to say something sooner or later.

Ben waited, staring.



MJ made this <3
#4
The weight of his stare was as heavy as the tension she thought they worked through prior to the first letter from T. It was oppressive, frightening even. Melody knew he was waiting for her to speak, to start screaming, to throw the steaming cup of broth before her in his face as she did the wine. He was waiting for her volatile reaction, when, really, she had nothing left to say. Nothing that would fix things, nothing that would make it so he'd want to stay with her in the end.

Funny, she really thought they might've made it to their first anniversary the night they made love on the parlor floor.

She kept her hands folded in her lap and her gaze trained towards the napkin's edges. Ben had to know she knew, he had to realize there were no secrets left between them. She could've laughed if she didn't want to fall apart into a hot mess of tears. Secrets were always their downfall. If Ben wanted to say something, he would.

Melody remained silent.


[Image: dqAG6wz.png]
beautiful set by mj
#5
At first he was frustrated when she didn't say anything, but then he realized he recognized this. This was her victim thing that she did, like when she said stupid things like sure, let's get a divorce, I'll go live on the streets so you can be happy, Ben (paraphrased, obviously). She was just waiting for him to say something so that she could lean into the unfairness of the situation; so that she could be the martyr. Maybe the way she'd dressed for lunch was even part of it, to make her look all the more pitiful.

It usually worked, was the thing. Ben had stepped in so many times to try and bolster her confidence, or to reassure her that he cared about her despite all her flaws. He usually bent over backwards trying to make her believe they could recover from whatever had happened, and that it wasn't her fault (or at least not entirely her fault). Most days, however, he didn't have to spill ink on discarded letters before he threw them away because he was worried she might be desperate enough to go through his trash to figure out what was going on, rather than just asking him.

He picked up his spoon, but rather than eat anything with it he leaned his chin on his knuckles, still watching her. Maybe it wasn't fair to her that Elliot existed; maybe it wasn't fair that she hadn't known about him before now. But it wasn't fair to Ben that he didn't feel as though he could safely throw a letter away in his own personal study.

He waited.

The following 1 user Likes Reuben Crouch's post:
   Marianne Finch


MJ made this <3
#6
The longer the silence stretched on the more ridiculous Melody felt for coming down for lunch at all. She obviously wasn't going to be able to stomach anything, and the energy in the room was almost ... angry. (Melody supposed he had a right to be angry since she violated his privacy in her search, but she maintained that she was right to do so. He was withholding secrets, secrets that if anyone discovered would ruin them both further than they had already fallen. Not that it mattered, really. Eventually, be it tomorrow or a year from now, one or both of them were likely going to insist upon the divorce.)

She eyed the broth, felt the reaffirming roll of her stomach, and decided this was a foolish plan. Neither of them would breach the silence first, it seemed, and she certainly wasn't going to force herself into vomiting at the table because of the strong smelling broth. Standing, Melody quietly tucked in her chair without so much as a glance towards Ben and turned to go back into her room.


[Image: dqAG6wz.png]
beautiful set by mj
#7
Ben watched as she stood to leave, feeling a wealth of different things all at once. He was a little annoyed at this act she was putting on — they both knew what she knew, so what was the point of pretending she hadn't seen the letters at this point? He almost felt like her coming downstairs at all was trying to bait him into something, but he wasn't sure what. A fight? An apology? Some sort of defense for his actions?

He did feel they were defensible — it was before he had married her, and she'd known the sort of reputation he'd had. He'd never told her he was a good man, or that he would make a good husband. In fact, he'd told her the opposite, several times, and she just refused to believe him until the moment she saw it with her own eyes. She must have felt entitled to going through his things because she felt he shouldn't be keeping any secrets from her, but he felt justified even in that. He'd only kept from telling her because he knew she would react poorly, and her behavior right now was proof positive that he'd guessed right on that account.

"Goodbye," he called, once she was already past the door. He tossed the spoon back down to the table and sat back in his chair, wondering where the hell he was supposed to go from here.

The following 1 user Likes Reuben Crouch's post:
   Marianne Finch


MJ made this <3
#8
It was nearing supper when Melody dared to venture from her room again. The persistent nausea resulted in a long afternoon of misery until she could stand the uncomfortable stickiness that came with being sick no longer. She summoned water for a bath and washed quickly, if only so she could go burrow under her blankets once more. Ben hadn't sought her out after his frustrated goodbye was said as she left the dining room, so she was under the impression they were in Paris all over again.

Unfortunately for Melody, the door to his bedroom was ajar, meaning she would have to risk seeing him on the walk back to her own sanctuary. She was determined not to look in, not to give in to the burning urge to say something to clue him into her confusion. But, the distinct sound of rustling stopped her dead in her tracks. Her brows furrowed in confusion as she recognized his suitcase on the bed.

His suitcase.

Ben was leaving.

Although she knew she shouldn't, Melody pushed the door open the rest of the way but remained firmly in the hallway. "You're leaving?" She asked quietly, both surprised and not at all by this turn of events.

The following 1 user Likes Melody Crouch's post:
   Marianne Finch

[Image: dqAG6wz.png]
beautiful set by mj
#9
Ben hadn't made his mind up to leave all at once. He'd left the lunch table without eating anything and gone back to the study, where he'd collected all the letters pertaining to Elliot. He folded them and shrunk them to a fraction of their initial size, then tucked them away in an interior pocket. No more snooping for you. He sat restlessly for several minutes, then decided to get rid of everything else in the study, too. He bundled up things that should go to Jewell's office and made a trip to the post office to rent a large owl to carry them all in one trip. He discarded things that should have been thrown away already. He sorted through personal letters and burned anything he wouldn't have wanted Melody to see. Then he burned anything left in the personal stack — sensitive or no, he couldn't stomach the idea of her going through letters from his friends while he was gone. Then he burned everything in the waste basket, too. He dumped a too-large pile in at once and sent a cloud of smoke into the study; he kicked the papers in and opened a window.

He took off, leaving the house and walking aimlessly around Irvingly. He passed their house three times before he could bring himself to enter it again. That was where the idea came from, to leave: the realization that being in the same house with her was bringing on a visceral sensation of dread. After that, everything else hit him like an avalanche. He'd spilled ink on a half written letter today to keep her from reading it. He'd burned letters from friends because he couldn't trust her to stay away from them. What was he doing? Why was he here?

He wasn't thinking clearly, or else he would have remembered to shut the door behind him. He looked up at her question, then back at his wardrobe, kicking himself for the mistake. "Yeah," he said simply.

The following 2 users Like Reuben Crouch's post:
   Cassius Lestrange, Dionisia Fisk


MJ made this <3
#10
Oh.

Well, that was it then, wasn't it? Her eyes burned with tears she would sooner die than let slip. Ben was leaving, and he wasn't even going to tell her. Just as he wasn't planning to tell her about his son, or that he told Arthur of their sham of a marriage. Ben was just a well of secrets and it somehow nearly always resulted in anger. Maybe they really should have applied for the divorce.

"What was the point of promising a fresh start?" She asked quickly before she could stop herself from doing so. "We were going to take a trip, to try and be happy together. Was that just the heat of the moment?"


[Image: dqAG6wz.png]
beautiful set by mj
#11
Ben stopped in his tracks, staring at her. The fuck was she talking about, a fresh start? If she'd really believed they were starting fresh, she wouldn't have gone through his things like a thief in the night. She would have talked to him. That's what married people did; they talked to each other. What, did she expect a fresh start to just mean he'd redouble his efforts, and she could do whatever she pleased?

This was the same sort of shit she'd pulled in Paris. She didn't trust him, she never had, and she never would. It didn't matter what he said or what they agreed to, after all their arguments. The next time she felt insecure, or uncertain about something, whether it was founded on anything or not, she'd just go violate his boundaries once again.

This was not normal, he was just now beginning to fully realize. His relationship with Melody was not normal. Elliot's mother had told her husband she was pregnant with another man's child before she married him. Dez and Art had been through hell. Some people trusted each other. Some people loved each other.

Melody had said she loved him, but if this was her way of demonstrating love, Ben wanted no part of it.

"I think it might take more than a holiday at this point," he said dryly.

The following 2 users Like Reuben Crouch's post:
   Cassius Lestrange, Marianne Finch


MJ made this <3
#12
She sighed. Obviously, a holiday wouldn't do anything but force them to spend time together. Time they likely desperately needed for their relationship to work in the end. "Would you have told me about him?" She asked rather than focus on the bitterness of his reply. "You knew for weeks, you told Arthur. Would you have told me?"


[Image: dqAG6wz.png]
beautiful set by mj
#13
Well, they were finally going to talk about it, he supposed. He had no desire to do so — talking to her about it when he was so angry at her almost felt unfair to Elliot and his mother, in a way, as though it would sully them by association — but he couldn't just ignore her, and she didn't look like she had any plans to retreat.

"No," he admitted. "I knew you wouldn't understand."



MJ made this <3
#14
"I wouldn't understand?" She echoed, the calmness leaving her for the first time. Ben was as bad as a hussy if not worst, Melody had no misconceptions about just how many women he likely slept with over the years. It was why she was as terrified as she was that he would have an affair.

"Tell me what I wouldn't have understood. That my husband was promiscuous prior to our wedding? No, I'm pretty familiar with that bit. That he, like presumably any man, would want to know more about his son? I wouldn't have blamed you for it." It would've been difficult for her to stomach, and she certainly would've feared him growing closer to the boy's mother, but she would've tried for him. Which was what a fresh start was meant to be, wasn't it?

She shook her head and rubbed her eyes tiredly. Then, looking at him with a sad expression, Melody added almost defeatedly, "A fresh start was meant to be for the both of us. You were meant to try and trust me, too."


[Image: dqAG6wz.png]
beautiful set by mj
#15
"How?" he challenged, throwing the shirt in his hands into the suitcase more forcefully than necessary. "How the hell am I supposed to trust you when you do something like this? You didn't even ask. You didn't give me a chance to be honest about it," he argued. He looked back at his wardrobe, but was too distracted to even see any of the clothes inside it. He pretended to look for clothes, then gave up and leaned one arm heavily against the door of the wardrobe. His eyes were still directed inside, though he wasn't looking at anything. "I didn't know what you'd do if I told you," he eventually said.



MJ made this <3
#16
"I tried to! I came to you when I thought things were unsettled, I asked you. And you said it was work." No, she hadn't asked him directly, but she had given him an opening to at least try and be honest with her. Instead, he lied and blamed it on something else entirely. How was that trusting? How was that an avenue for a healthy marriage?!

"You didn't even try to find out." She said after a long minute.


[Image: dqAG6wz.png]
beautiful set by mj

View a Printable Version


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)
Forum Jump:
·