Updates
Welcome to Charming
Welcome to Charming, the year is now 1895. It’s time to join us and immerse yourself in scandal and drama interlaced with magic both light and dark.

Where will you fall?

Featured Stamp

Add it to your collection...

Did You Know?
Braces, or suspenders, were almost universally worn due to the high cut of men's trousers. Belts did not become common until the 1920s. — MJ
Had it really come to this? Passing Charles Macmillan back and forth like an upright booby prize?
Entry Wounds


Private
I've got a hundred million reasons to walk away; I just need one good one to stay
#1
September 24th, 1891 — Emrys' Home, Bristol
She wasn’t certain she would be able to contain herself with him so close. It was a normal refrain when she near him, absence usually muddying her best-laid plans to make him wait, but tonight was new territory. She hated it.

She knew something was wrong, had never been ‘right’ after her surprising him months ago, but the depth of his deception was overwhelming. Almost as corrosive to her pride as his dogged insistence to keep her in dark about everything. She had kept her word and he’d kept his secrets, but for what? She’d honored his privacy and he’d been courting a girl that still belonged in the nursery. So much for loyalty and all the ridiculous things her irrational heart decided existed between them. She was the true fool here. For months, she’d allowed her emotions to run unchecked whenever thoughts of Emrys Selwyn came to mind. She’d dreamed things; been naïve enough to believe the words he wrote her and the ones he whispered to her in passion; she’d made the single mistake she’d sworn never to make again and now she would pay for it.

After the ridiculous gossip magazine announced his courtship, she held her peace until she was safely back to her quarters. She maintained her silence until she’d warded her rooms, and then she broke. The anger and feeling of foolishness, she could freely admit, but the heartbreak, the feeling of loss was more than she could stomach. She did not lose, and she certainly did not love. One, both, or neither was true.

***
She’d waited a week for this ‘reunion’ of sorts. He’d written her nothing after the Witch Weekly bombshell and all she’d written was her confirmation to expect her Friday evening as if nothing had changed. She’d had days to work through her most troublesome emotions, enough time to assemble her armor and solidify her plan for the evening. He most likely expected hysterics or some sort of screaming display of feminine outrage, but she had no interest in giving him what he expected. No, she would let him choke on the anticipation of her reaction. Let him feel an ounce of the anxiety she’d been drowning in.

She still dressed for his eye; still wore the smoky quartz necklace and earrings he’d given her so early into their arrangement. All signs pointed to a witch at ease in the familiar home of her lover, but looks were deceptive things. She'd managed to greet him with a chaste kiss even as the gesture left her feeling soiled. She'd maintained the brittle facade of small talk as they ate, even as she had to fight to swallow the few bites she dared try. She wanted him miserable and guilty, but the longer she waited for him to say something, the more ill she felt.

Even escaping to the familiar privacy of one of his drawing rooms only tightened the knots in her chest. She'd given him time (so much time) to confess his failures, to lie to her, anything besides this unspoken tension between them. He'd had every opportunity to be a gentleman - or even a cad - but still, she waited. When she retreated moved away to the fireplace, she let the heat fuel her resolve. She'd waited long enough for him. "There seems to be something you failed to mention in our time together, my dear." The endearment was spoken out of habit, but the fire in her eyes and tension in her body were at odds with the sentiment. The man dear to her was more a stranger to her now than he had ever been.


The following 1 user Likes Angelica Selwyn's post:
   Melody Crouch

[Image: NpMgQU7.png]
MJ made this miracle!
#2
Something was wrong with Professor Vorona. Emrys had noticed it from the moment of their first kiss this evening, not because of anything she'd overtly done or said, but rather because of the way she was carrying herself. There was something off, something that was bothering her. Of course he wondered if it had to do with him — he was an inherently vain man and self-aware enough to know it — but it could just as easily have been anything else. She'd gone back to work for the school year, so it might have been something to do with that. Work strain, something a student had done or said, some qualm with Headmaster Black. That seemed more reasonable than anything else he could come up with, because between them nothing had changed from the end of August, when he'd last seen her, until tonight.

Of course, just because nothing had changed on his end didn't mean that nothing had changed on hers. He'd had liaisons before (though none quite like this) and they had drawn to a natural close. Sometimes he grew tired with them and ended things, but just as often it was the other party who had moved on with their life. Priorities changed, desires shifted, and sometimes he didn't fit into the new landscape. That could be what was happening here. Three weeks ago everything had been glorious, but by now perhaps she was working up the courage to call things off.

If that was the case, he wished she would have done it in a letter. He wasn't sure he'd be able to keep his features neutral through a labored confession. But he might have been wrong; it might have just been stress from work. Maybe they weren't doomed just yet. Someday, of course — in his experience these things never lasted forever — but maybe not tonight.

If he was hoping to make it through the evening following their usual pattern of things and avoid catastrophe, though, her next sentence wasn't particularly confidence inspiring. Emrys didn't know what to say. It wasn't that he'd been perfectly honest with her, of course; he was never perfectly honest with anyone. It was just that he didn't know what she was referring to specifically, which made it difficult to determine how he ought to respond. What he ended up saying was "Oh?" with both eyebrows slightly raised. It wasn't particularly articulate, but it was also unlikely to get him in much more trouble while he figured out what she'd heard.




Lou made this! <3
#3
"'Oh?'" It sounded no more articulate coming from her. "All you give me is 'oh.'" No more articulate, but twice as incredulous. That he had the audacity to give her the most noncommittal verbal response possible was infuriating, but she was prepared, in her own way. As much as a spontaneous confession would vindicate her, it would have been suspect. He wasn't the sort to volunteer information; a change to that trait would be its own web of complication. Still, this foreseeable response galled her.

Collecting herself, or at least the reins on her growing sense of indignation, Angelica offered him another thorny little breadcrumb. "It would seem congratulations are in order if the Witch Weekly can be believed for any bit of truth." She watched him for any tell in his manner, any hint of his thoughts. "If they have maligned you with so ridiculous a match, a gentleman could always demand a retraction. So, which will it be?" There would be no retraction, she knew in her heart the truth of the rumor, but she gave him room to lie. She also offered him a path to the truth, but as she set her shoulders for his answer, Angelica braced for attrition warfare.



[Image: NpMgQU7.png]
MJ made this miracle!
#4
She was angry, and angry with him. Her tone left no room for doubt, though it wasn't until she mentioned Witch Weekly that he finally put together what she was angry about. His eyebrows raised higher. He honestly hadn't expected a confrontation over his courtship (soon to be more) of Miss Cosgrove. He had considered that she might be annoyed about it, or possibly even irate enough to call things off between them, but when he'd imagined it the scenario had always been that she'd sent a cool, carefully worded letter and said her goodbyes. If she was really upset about his seeing someone else — which she obviously was — what was to be gained by discussing it in person?

"Oh," he said again, this time with more meaning behind the word. He wanted to know whether she truly thought Miss Cosgrove ridiculous in any sense or whether she was only spitting fire in the heat of the moment, but knew better than to try and ask. "You didn't strike me as a subscriber to Witch Weekly," he said. It may have sounded like a feeble attempt at humor, but it was really more of a stalling tactic than anything. How did he get through this argument unscathed? What did she want? If she'd already determined to call things off, she would have done it in a letter. The fact that she'd come tonight and sat through an entire dinner before bringing this up meant that she was after something, but for the life of him he couldn't figure out what it was.




Lou made this! <3
#5
"Don't. Don't you dare." The venom in the warning almost surprised her as it oozed from her words. He appeared almost surprised by her reaction as if she was at fault for this game he was playing. "My reading habits are not the point of contention." As if he hadn't written her of rumors first in their entanglement! He wrote her about the slanderous Watchword article alleging some unrequited love match with Felix. "You mean to marry Clarissa Cosgrove, of all people, and you didn't say a word." The lies of omission were damning, but the subject of his supposed fascination baffled her. Clarissa Cosgrove over her. The idea was laughable, or it had been until she saw it in print.

"You hid this from me and I will know why. Why?" She was happy to wave goodbye to subtlety, but she would have to tread carefully. She heard the waver in her voice, cursing the hurt that appeared before she could force it in back. The crush of questions was growing and her ability to hold it all was rapidly dwindling. She'd examined his motives from every angle she could imagine, but she still couldn't understand why this was how he's chosen to move in the world.


The following 1 user Likes Angelica Selwyn's post:
   Melody Crouch

[Image: NpMgQU7.png]
MJ made this miracle!
#6
"Well, that's certainly melodramatic," he responded dryly. This was hardly the way to get through the argument unscathed, as was his original intention, but her reaction had irritated him. It was probably the derision directed at Miss Cosgrove that did it. It wasn't that he was enamored with her, by any means, but he had put a good deal of time and effort into selecting the right bride from the marriage market that season. Calling Miss Cosgrove anything less than an ideal choice was calling his judgement into question, which in turn wounded his pride. If there was one thing that would cause him to lose his cool during an argument, it was wounded pride.

"I haven't been hiding anything from you," he said testily. "What were you expecting, a dossier on everyone I've danced with this season? I didn't think a discussion of my courtship would be particularly arousing foreplay."


The following 1 user Likes Emrys Selwyn's post:
   Angelica Selwyn


Lou made this! <3
#7
He could have hexed her and she would have been less shocked by the response. His dismissal landed like a shot to the gut, her breath catching somewhere in her throat along with her heart. "As melodramatic as courting a girl for an empty veneer to your pride?" She tossed back snidely. This she was familiar with: the dismissal of her feelings, the belittling of her opinions. She'd had this and worse from Victor, but the crumbling of her marriage had been a gradual decline at first. This was an earthquake when she had prepared for a siege.

"You have been hiding for months." She gave right back, her voice rising in her own defense. "I do not care whom you dance with," Lie the first. "I care that you promised yourself to that silly child while coming to my bed. Are you truly so delusional to believe that I would welcome this?" She forced herself to break from her glaring, to turn her face back to the fire and breathe. "I ask you again: why her?" And why not me?



[Image: NpMgQU7.png]
MJ made this miracle!
#8
Emrys bit his tongue, knowing full well that whatever response came to mind first would be a mistake. He'd always been a bit out of step with Victorian morality, so he saw no particular issue with carrying on multiple affairs at once, particularly when they were each of such a patently different flavor that they could hardly claim to be competition for each other. He thought it a bit hypocritical, too, that she wanted to berate him for infidelity when she had been perfectly content to engage in all sorts of delightfully wanton behavior without so much as a formal agreement between the two of them. It wasn't as though she was a chaste virgin, or a model of morality. She was just a slightly different brand of sinner, for all she'd put on her sanctimonious airs at the moment.

"I don't think that's a particularly useful question," he pointed out, tone level. If she was jealous, she was jealous; it had nothing to do with Miss Cosgrove, really, so defending her would only be a waste of his breath. "If what you're trying to say is that you refuse to see me if I marry, then you ought to just say it."




Lou made this! <3
#9
She fought the urge to roll her eyes, but the impulse morphed into a defiant plant of her hands on her hips. For a moment, she was reminded of a lifetime of arguing with her twin, the posture and bickering were certainly familiar, but the stakes kept her from doing something sisterly (namely throwing the first non-precious object in reach at his head). She did not receive the credit she was due for restraining her urges.

"It is the most pertinent question to this debate, thank you very much." She held back for a moment when he changed tactics on her. Not seeing him again was the opposite of her hopes. How could he question that? "If that is what I wanted to say, I would have." She batted his statement aside like the pointless evasion it was. "I am not the one running away. And I have every right to know why in the name of Merlin you would make such a decision."

Her distance from him was essential to her not slapping his smug face, but her feet pulled her in his direction regardless. She caught her own movement and redirected to a seat across from him, her hands clamped firmly on the headrest. "You chose her. You have me and you chose her. I want to know why." If her voice wavered on that, she chose to ignore it.



[Image: NpMgQU7.png]
MJ made this miracle!
#10
"It's not the same," Emrys bit back, although it felt needless to say it aloud. She must have known that there was no comparison between her and Clarissa Cosgrove, and she was only needling him about it in order to provoke him. He hadn't so much as kissed Miss Cosgrove, so while he thought her pretty enough for his purposes he was hardly passionate about her. He hadn't sent her expensive jewelry whose color made her eyes light up like stars.

"You're not this naive," he argued (perhaps again an unwise choice of conversational tactic, but he was too frustrated by her verbal assault to restrain himself). "You've been in society long enough to know marriage seldom means anything else except marriage. So I don't understand what you're trying to get from me." If she was planning to poke him until some declaration of love tumbled out, either for her or for Clarissa Cosgrove, she'd miscalculated.


The following 1 user Likes Emrys Selwyn's post:
   Angelica Selwyn


Lou made this! <3
#11
He was A) an imbecile or B) purposefully ignorant. Good sense reminded Angelica that the true cause of his dolt-like answer was something more permanent: C) Emrys Selwyn was a man.

Angelica's eyebrows must have been someplace past her hairline when he dared to throw her more meaningless drivel. "You are correct, on one point at least: Miss Cosgrove and I are not the same by any measure. You have chosen a lesser woman for reasons I cannot fathom." She watched his face as he took in her words and it only added to her confusion. What right did he have to appear inconvenienced by the very question of her future happiness?

"I know far better than you what marriage is and is not." She felt her metaphorical hackles rise at that. Even if she had enjoyed the "perfect" marriage - she would be the one with grievances. What did a second son know of her struggles? She crossed in front of the furniture, forcing herself down in the chair opposite him. Nothing good would come of being closer, but the urge to shove (poke violently, slap, sob uncontrollably, what have you, etc.) was clawing at her. His last lash at her baffled into near silence.

"What I "want" seems a pointless thing to share, as you have decided to discredit my opinion," she gave with a clipped tone. "And I flatly refuse to see you as a victim of fate," she scoffed. "Marriage means nothing for those without options, but you have a world of options." She couldn't truly expect a dawning realization and a heartfelt apology to never stray, but a witch could fantasize."What I want - again - is the truth. You. Do. Not. Need. Her." Angelica gave each syllable a condescending bite.



[Image: NpMgQU7.png]
MJ made this miracle!
#12
"You want me to marry you." The realization hit him like a glass of water thrown in his face, and the words had left his lips before he'd had a chance to think better of them. Of course he had at one point considered marrying her. That was why he'd made her acquaintance in the first place, at the dueling tournament. That felt like a lifetime ago, though. The woman that he'd come to know had nothing in common with the neat assessment that he'd made of her in his notebook, back in January. The truth was that he had never considered marrying Angelica. By the time he'd truly come to know her, he'd dismissed the idea entirely. He'd thought that because of their arrangement, she would have discarded the idea as well. She had all the freedoms that unwed women lacked, and more. Why would she want to marry, particularly if she already had him eating out of her hand at every available opportunity?

But she did want it, apparently, and now her jealousy made sense. She understood there was no competition between her and Clarissa Cosgrove for his passion, his desire. He didn't write Miss Cosgrove the sorts of letters he wrote to her, nor did he send her gifts of the same caliber. Unknowingly, however, he'd planned to give Miss Cosgrove a gift she coveted more than jewelry.

"My darling," he said softly, rising from his seat to move towards her.




Lou made this! <3
#13
She did not like this look on him. For a breath, he looked like she'd struck him, which was tempting, but what followed left her entirely unsettled. He looked at her as if he'd solved some mystery; as if he could puzzle her out. It seemed unlikely, as his actions spoke to a complete lack of understanding of a woman's mind, but ignorance never stopped men before.

"I want you to trust me," she pushed back. "The other should be obvious." She made a point of looking away from him, a hint of a pout to her lips. How he could say such a thing as if it was a revelation was mindboggling. It was an insult for him to think her incapable of such a wish. Doubt gave her a strong prod at the implication. Was this all because she'd gone to his bed without a promise for a more formal union? The independence she loved so dearly, her acceptance of his gifts and giving him her own, she'd played his mistress for months. How could she hold it against him if he treated her accordingly?

The tightness in her chest twisted deeper as her mind mapped out this realization. She flinched at his change of tone, the understanding that sounded too near to pity for her liking. She rose when he moved, unwilling to have him looming any larger over her than his height already allowed. There was something about holding her ground that felt much like dignity, something of hers that had taken a beating in the past week.

"Do not patronize me." She held up a hand in a weak gesture for him to stop his approach. "How can you call me that when you chose her? You would give everything to a sheltered child who offers you little advantage and for what? You would give her your name, your protection," she caught herself before the obnoxious hitch in her throat could become something truly embarrassing. It was hard enough seeing him in public and knowing she should keep her distance. The idea of him and Miss Cosgrove together was nauseating. How long before seeing her on his arm was replaced by Cosgrove all smiles at the announcement of their first child? Before the mischievous, adorable child Angel could imagine in her dreams would be a reality for another woman? Merlin, it was too much to dwell on.


The following 3 users Like Angelica Selwyn's post:
   Emrys Selwyn, Holly Scrimgeour, Melody Crouch

[Image: NpMgQU7.png]
MJ made this miracle!
#14
Trust her. She knew him well enough, Emrys thought, to understand what a difficult request that was. He'd built his life on closely guarded secrets. He'd carefully cultivated a persona of mystery, so that even his friends were never entirely sure of his motivation. By this point, an inclination not to trust others was a pillar of his personality. She might as well have asked for half his estate; it would have been easier for him to deliver on it.

"I'm not trying to patronize," he replied, almost wearily. The irritation in his tone had disappeared, but he was still unsure how he was going to weather this conversation. He couldn't even imagine a positive resolution to this predicament, much less see a path to reach one. "It means nothing," he tried to argue, though without much hope of convincing her. If he really wanted her to believe he had no particular attachment to Miss Cosgrove, he would have to explain his reasons behind wanting to marry in the first place, which was out of the question.




Lou made this! <3
#15
"It means everything." She pushed back again, but the fire was mixed with a plea for understanding. "Or, if it is nothing, as you say, you would not have kept this from me." She was running in the dark and hitting walls searching for him. How could this be so difficult for him to understand? "I see your secrets, Mr. Selwyn," It felt wrong to address him so formally now, "I see your secrets and I welcome them and you deny me. I had a glimpse of you - the real you - and you brush me aside to go to her." Angelica had given every face imaginable to the mystery woman she knew was enjoying her elusive pirate the night she'd encountered him in his study. The idea that the youngest Cosgrove was the woman to know all of him was an insult. "How is she more worthy of you than I am? How do you touch me as you do, write the words you do, and then look through me?"

She found his eyes before she spoke again, her arms crossing tight over her chest to keep from shaking. "I do not want to lose you, but I will not be your mistress while she takes your name, I cannot. Emrys, please." The ground beneath her feet was gone. This was falling without a sense of direction or time, only darkness greeting her fear that he wouldn't lift a finger to catch her.


The following 2 users Like Angelica Selwyn's post:
   Melody Crouch, Yuri Podsnapper

[Image: NpMgQU7.png]
MJ made this miracle!
#16
She didn't understand half as much as she thought she did. There was a competition in her mind that simply didn't exist in reality; he'd never passed up an opportunity to spend time with her in favor of a social event with Miss Cosgrove. And he honestly hadn't been trying to keep his courtship of Miss Cosgrove from her, except that he had never gone out of his way to bring it up. He'd treated the subject with the same apathy with all of his siblings, though; he simply wasn't one to announce his news when the rumor mill could handle it just as effectively. She had conflated this ordeal with Miss Cosgrove with something he had been hiding from her, because he hid it from almost everyone. She might say she saw his secrets and welcomed them, but Emrys knew better than to think she would really be so understanding if the truth were on the table.

His mind was stuck on all of the things he'd already said, which he could say again and again tonight without ever making her believe them. It's not the same, you don't understand, things aren't like that with her, it means nothing. None were likely to have much of an impact on her; she would think he was lying, trying to brush off her concerns, patronizing, when really he was being more honest with her in this moment than he had been in any previous conversation. He just couldn't explain why, because she wouldn't understand, and since she didn't know why she was never going to believe him.

Then she rolled out her ultimatum, and she used his first name. Emrys wasn't sure which affected him more, but for a moment he was speechless as he tried to push through a cloud of emotion in his chest. "Angelica," he breathed, pain evident in his voice. This might be the last time he spoke to her like this, if she was true to her word. He'd come too far with Miss Cosgrove to change direction now, even if he wanted to; the engagement ring was tucked into the top drawer of the desk in his study, and all the plans made. He could still back out (though not without causing a storm of rumors), but if he did, what then? Marry Angelica? Marry her, and take her into his home? Marry this woman who wanted access to all of his secrets, to know every piece of him? He hadn't even been able to keep her entirely disentangled from his other life during their ongoing affair in the summer, so it was folly to think that he could keep his secrets to himself if they were married. Someday she'd discover something she couldn't cope with, whatever she said now, and this would all come crashing down.

And even if she never learned a secret she wasn't comfortable with, he couldn't have married her. Marriage was permanent, but every observation Emrys had made of the world, all his past experiences, brought him to the conclusion that love was not. Even if she never became disgusted with him or never grew to hate him, sooner or later she would at least be apathetic. When that happened (not if), the only thing that would save him would be putting as much distance between the two of them as possible, to try and numb the pain. Sharing a life with her, living in the same house as her, would be unbearable. He'd fallen in and out of love before in his life, but he had never felt like this. If he continued to feel this way when her feelings shifted to something else, having to continue seeing her every day would kill him, he was sure.

So this might be the last time, if she was serious about the ultimatum she'd laid down. He couldn't see a way around it, at least not with the wheels that had already been set in motion continuing to spin. If she'd said this months ago he might have put off searching for a wife entirely, for years if necessary, for the chance at keeping her just that much longer. But he couldn't see his way back down from the precipice they were on now, when she had demanded access to his secrets and Miss Cosgrove was expecting a proposal tomorrow. So: if this was the last time, what should he say to her?

"I see you," he said quietly. "I couldn't look through you if I tried."


The following 2 users Like Emrys Selwyn's post:
   Angelica Selwyn, Melody Crouch


Lou made this! <3

Possibly Related Threads…
Thread / Author Replies Views Last Post
View a Printable Version


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)
Forum Jump:
·