Updates
Welcome to Charming
Welcome to Charming, the year is now 1895. It’s time to join us and immerse yourself in scandal and drama interlaced with magic both light and dark.

Where will you fall?

Featured Stamp

Add it to your collection...

Did You Know?
Did you know? Jewelry of jet was the haute jewelry of the Victorian era. — Fallin
What she got was the opposite of what she wanted, also known as the subtitle to her marriage.
all dolled up with you


Private
the higher I climb the farther I fall
#33
Melody paused with her trembling hand on the bannister. Was this not enough? Did he have to insist upon working through every kink of their newfound agreement tonight? She was seconds away from crumbling, her knees were already weak beneath her. Surely, whatever Ben had to talk about could wait until morning.

Turning back to face him, Melody waited in silence for a further explanation.


[Image: dqAG6wz.png]
beautiful set by mj
#34
He'd said it before he'd really thought it through. He should have let her go. Melody turned to look at him from her position at the bottom of the stairs, and Ben hesitated. He felt weightless, all of the sudden. His stomach could have been outside of his body, with the way his nerves were feeling. What did he want to tell her?

Aldous knows.

He wished he had a drink. No, better still, wished he was already drunk — then he wouldn't have to think about this before he said it. He'd made so many mistakes over the past few days and he couldn't tell if this was about to be added to the list or not. She deserved to know, didn't she? It was the biggest betrayal of the past forty-eight hours, and of their entire marriage — no, their entire relationship, all the way from meeting her at the High Street shop up through today. He'd promised her he'd never tell anyone about that, that he would protect her from the consequences of her panicked actions on that night, and he'd failed. This wasn't the time to tell her, when she was already feeling betrayed and broken and hopeless, but if he didn't tell her now he wasn't sure he ever would, and she deserved to know what he'd done. He recognized that this was hard for her — harder for her, maybe, than it had ever been for him — and she was still trying to do the best she could for him, in the end. Keeping their marriage intact so that he could have access to their child, keeping herself in a loveless and miserable situation — she was doing that because she thought it was what he wanted. She deserved to know that he'd gone and broken his most fundamental promise to her. They might not have had traditional wedding vows, but this might as well have been his: I'll keep you safe, I'll keep your secrets.

Ben put one hand on the arm of the sofa, the other on the cushion next to him. He focused on the physical sensation of the fabric on his fingertips for a moment, trying to replicate the grounding sensation of Art's hands on his wrists earlier. He still felt adrift, but he could do this. "I —" he started, but his voice was shaking and he stopped, not trusting himself to be able to finish the sentence. I told Aldous. He knows everything. I'm sorry.

He tried to imagine what she would do, after he said it. Would she still be willing to stay? Or would she break in the face of it? Having to routinely see Aldous, knowing that he knew such a deeply personal thing about her, might have been too much to bear. If she wanted to leave, to divorce or separate, Ben didn't think he could have blamed her. It might be even worse if she stayed — the two of them living in this house, refusing to touch each other, and her so obviously in pain. This betrayal would stay with them. It would be in the air between them for every conversation, the subtext of every shared glance. It would poison their relationship as parents before their child was even born. Ben didn't think he could cope with that.

How were they going to claw their way out of this? Ben wanted better for his child than what Melody had just offered for them. Maybe she thought that could work, based on the example her own parents had set for her, but Ben wanted more than that. He wanted to teach his child things. He wanted family outings. He wanted laughter and love and life in their home. He didn't know if his own parents had really been in love — he'd thought so at the time, but had learned since that such things were rare in married life — but there had definitely been love, between them, and trust and respect. It had been obvious to him, growing up, and he was sure it would be equally obvious to his child if he and Melody lacked it.

"I love you," he said suddenly, rising from the sofa. "I want to make this work. I know you have no reason to think it can. I haven't given you any reason to think I could — that I could be a good husband," he admitted, cheeks flushing deeply. "But I want to. I love you."

The following 2 users Like Reuben Crouch's post:
   Aldous Crouch, Melody Crouch


MJ made this <3
#35
The only example of love Melody had prior to the insanity with Ben existed solely in books. Books that she snubbed as a teenager, books that she refused to believe were true. The knights never came for the damsels, she used to insist. Love wasn't a fairy tale; it was a cold and broken reality that ruined women and left them destitute. Melody didn't used to even want love. It wasn't tangible, or something that could be measured or understood. Love made people insane and act rashly.

And then, she fell in love with the rake Reuben Crouch.

And she loved him on her own for years. She buried her heartache deep within herself whilst he was in Canada, refused to acknowledge that what she felt for him could have been love. Infatuation, maybe. Lust, probably. Never love. A lover would never had allowed her letters to go unanswered, she forced herself to believe. A lover wouldn't abandon her as Ben had. And, still, Melody Finch was still willing to follow him into oblivion.

Melody Finch became Melody Crouch, and even then she remained hopeful that her love might one day be returned.

Nothing could've prepared her for the long desired admission.

No one could've told her how little she would believe in love when it finally came.

Gradually, she lowered herself to sit on the stairs, not trusting her legs to keep her standing. He seemed so sure, so confident, but the timing was so odd. Now that she had finally resolved herself to be the wife on the sidelines, to watch him experience happiness wherever else he found it, that was when the admission came. Hot, fat tears she didn't even know existed fell in streams down her cheeks. Ben loved her, or so he claimed. Why didn't she believe it?

"It's been a long two days, Ben," she said, her voice shaking with the breakdown that was sure to come. "Tell me that when you've had time to think if you still mean it."

The following 4 users Like Melody Crouch's post:
   Aldous Crouch, Camilla Lytton, Cassius Lestrange, Reuben Crouch

[Image: dqAG6wz.png]
beautiful set by mj
#36
It was as though he'd dealt her a blow, both with how the words felt leaving him and how she reacted to them. Ben watched her anxiously, and took a few steps closer to the stairs. When she moved to sit, for a moment he thought she was going to fall. Maybe it hadn't been fair to tell her that, either, but he meant it. He hadn't planned it, maybe hadn't even realized it a moment before he said it, but he believed it.

"I know," he said, moving to sit on the floor a few feet from the base of the stairs and looking up at her attentively. "I know. It sounds crazy. I sound crazy," he admitted. "But I don't want to leave. And I don't want you to go. Physically or... you know, mentally," he said, struggling to find words to express exactly what he meant. "I know you don't have any reason to believe I can do this, but give me a chance. Let me try. We've got time, right? We've got... eight months," he said, glancing towards her stomach. "So give me that long. To prove I mean it. And if you're not happy by then, then — we can figure out what happens next. Okay?" he offered. This was the point where he would have laid a reassuring hand on her knee or her shoulder, if he'd been allowed close enough to touch her, but they weren't there yet, and that was fine. For the first time in a long time, he was optimistic — stupidly, inexplicably optimist. They would get there. They could do this. He loved her.

The following 2 users Like Reuben Crouch's post:
   Camilla Lytton, Cassius Lestrange


MJ made this <3
#37
Ben was speaking, but all Melody heard was a loud buzzing sound in her ears. The insanity of his confession was the final crack in the deep dam Melody kept shoving all her feelings and thoughts behind. Seconds ago, she had made the decision for them to lead separate lives. It would've been painful and miserable and devastating, but he would've been happy. And, maybe one day, she could have been happy.

Without either listening to him or responding to any of it, Melody dropped her head to her knees and began to cry.

The following 1 user Likes Melody Crouch's post:
   Camilla Lytton

[Image: dqAG6wz.png]
beautiful set by mj
#38
He supposed he should have expected this. She'd been on the verge of tears all evening, and this was big.

He wanted to comfort her; didn't know how. He didn't think words would help. Words were cheap, even ones like I love you; they couldn't hold any real reassurances if she didn't believe them, and she had no reason to believe them.

He scooted to the bottom of the stair, as if being physically closer to her might help, but why would it? She wasn't looking at him, though, just crying. After a moment, he tentatively reached up and hooked his fingers around one ankle.



MJ made this <3
#39
Try as she might, Melody couldn't reseal the burst dam. Her arms wrapped tight around her knees as she cried, her chest heaved for breath before she couldn't calm herself enough to draw in. She cried for the love she dreamt of, for the baby they lost, for all her failures. A desperate part of her yearned to believe him, to allow the man who claimed to love her to hold her through her lowest moment. It would be so easy to sink down a step and fall into his lap. It would be so easy to allow his chivalry to deny the decision she made.

Love wasn't easy, it was so damn hard.

He reached for her to help her through it, and she couldn't let him. Not like this.

Melody allowed him to hold onto her ankle for a beat too long before lifting her head to wipe furiously at her cheeks. "You d- you don't me-mean it." She said through her hiccupping breaths. Then, slowly — deliberately — she pulled away from his touch. "You don't." She shook her head even as the heavy tears kept falling.


[Image: dqAG6wz.png]
beautiful set by mj
#40
He'd expected the refusal, and expected her to pull back. He put his hand back on the floor, still looking up at her. "I'll prove it," he promised earnestly. "Just — stay. Don't give up on me yet. Be here, tonight, and tomorrow, and give me a chance to prove it to you."

It seemed like the pair of them had spent half their marriage with one party or another disengaged, which might have been why it had taken him so long to come to this realization. He'd always known he cared about her, but he'd never been willing to admit to this label for it — because if he loved her, so what? It didn't change the facts, or the baggage, or the other feelings that clouded every conversation he had with her. And somehow, he supposed, it would have only served to make him more disappointed in himself. Because of the circumstances under which their marriage had begun he'd always had a ready excuse for why it wasn't working: he hadn't chosen this; he didn't want this; he didn't love her. He could check out whenever he didn't want to deal with it any more, and it was her fault, not his. Because if he admitted that he loved her, he would have had to come to terms with the fact that he just wasn't very good at this. Even with sentiment on his side, he failed her repeatedly. It was easier not to try at all, or at least not to really try, than it was to face the possibility of failure.

Well, failure wasn't an option anymore. They had a child to care for, or they would soon. They had a tiny life that would depend on them for love, and guidance, and look to them for an example of what life ought to be. They had to do better — Ben had to do better. It was time to grow up. He needed Melody on his side. He needed the two of them to be on the same team, so that they could fix things. He could take the initiative, but she had to be present and engaged if they were going to make any real progress — if they had any chance of being a real family. And he knew what would get her to stay present, because he knew her: that label he'd resisted for so long, but which described the feelings he'd been harboring for years so well. He loved her.

They could do this.

The following 2 users Like Reuben Crouch's post:
   Cassius Lestrange, Melody Crouch


MJ made this <3
#41
The promises he made were as hollow as their wedding vows. He believed it now when he thought them to be separating permanently, when he believed her to be out of reach. It was the thrill of the chase Ben thought himself in love with, not her. Marianne Finch was incorrect about many of her assumptions last night but a man loving a woman who was otherwise unattainable wasn't one of them. Melody could laugh if she wasn't so overwhelmingly sad.

'I want out,' Ben had said. Nothing about those three words resembled anything close to love.

She used the sleeve of her dress to wipe her face, having lost track of her handkerchief somewhere between the sofa and the stairs. The promises and quiet pleading were so unfair of him. Ben knew where her feelings stood all along, Melody was never shy about expressing her affection for him. And to use his declaration as a means to make her stay when she otherwise wouldn't was cruel. But, after all she'd put him through the last year, she owed him this bit of pain. This further shattering of her heart.

"Okay," she nodded quietly, still obviously unsure of the turn of events. "I won't." Not yet, anyway. Tomorrow would prove another story she was sure. Melody then tried to pull herself up on the bannister so that she may at last retreat for the evening, only to find herself too weak to lift more than a few inches from the step. "Can you ... I'd really like to go to bed now. Could you help me?" She asked without meeting his eyes.


[Image: dqAG6wz.png]
beautiful set by mj
#42
Ben's expression softened at her request. "Yeah," he said softly, almost as if he were afraid to say it out loud. This moment felt... fragile, though he wasn't sure what else could happen since she was already sitting on the floor and crying. He didn't want to do anything to break whatever composure she still had left. "Of course. If you want."

He moved towards her on the stairs, scooping her up with one arm below her legs and one behind her shoulders. He hadn't carried her like this since the night they'd eloped, before the potion had worn off and before he'd had a chance to think about what had happened, a chance to come down. The last time he'd carried her like this the only thought he'd had in his head was how happy the two of them were going to be together.

This was different. He wasn't sure either of them were going to be happy for a good long while, but they could get through this. Now that he was really here, and really willing to try, they could get through this.

He carried her up the stairs, down the hall to her room. He paused before the doorway, looking at her. "We can do this," he said softly.



MJ made this <3
#43
The last time Ben held her like this was the last time Melody thought herself to be sincerely happy, and even that happiness was tainted by her wrongdoings. For those few short hours they were happy, however fake it was. She knew Ben remembered every detail of that night, or so he claimed, but she often wondered if he remembered how wonderful it to be cherished in those few moments. Or was it all clouded by both the potion and his ire at her? She didn't dare to ask.

She tried not to lean into the embrace as her instincts screamed at her to do. Instead, she remained as rigid as she could in the position with her head lifted rather than sagged against his shoulder. He was just helping her up, not comforting her. There was a long road to travel before she would believe it safe to seek comfort in him again.

Melody looked up towards him as he spoke. She wished she understood his reasoning behind the sudden change of heart, just as she wished she could believe him without a doubt in her head. But, too much had happened. Just yesterday he couldn't even remain at home with her, and now today he loved her. It didn't make sense.

"We'll try," she said in response before gesturing for him to put her down. Really, what she wanted was a hug, but it felt wrong to even ask.


[Image: dqAG6wz.png]
beautiful set by mj

View a Printable Version


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)
Forum Jump:
·