I also tried this the other day and got April Ludgate as #1. This time the questions were different?, so we have...

River Tam (Firefly + Serenity): 87% (I know nothing about who this is /shrug)
Janis Ian (Mean Girls): 85%
Ms. Sharon Norbury (Mean Girls): 82%
Elizabeth Bennet (Pride and Prejudice): 81%
Brandon Stark (Game of Thrones): 80%
April Ludgate (Park and Recreation): 80%
Rust Cohle (True Detective): 80%
Abed Nadir (Community): 80%
Peggy Olson (Mad Men): 80%
Remus Lupin (Harry Potter): 78%
Sherlock Holmes (Sherlock): 78%
Bertram Gilfoyle (Silicon Valley): 78%
Peter Gregory (Silicon Valley): 78%
Toby Ziegler (The West Wing): 77%
Varys (Game of Thrones): 76%
Richard Hendricks (Silicon Valley): 76%
Fox Mulder (The X-Files): 76%
Alastor Moody (Harry Potter): 75%
Moaning Myrtle (Harry Potter): 75%
Gandalf (Lord of the Rings): 75%

Ew especially @ Sherlock, this time was not so nice. Except Remus Lupin, who is still my top Harry Potter character <3 April's still on there too, which is accurate. Also Mulder showed up this time, which... LOL. I feel like 90% of this is because I leaned ~arcane instead of mainstream.