+- Charming (https://charmingrp.com)
+-- Forum: OOC - The End (https://charmingrp.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Forum: The Archives (https://charmingrp.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=52)
+---- Forum: 1894 (https://charmingrp.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=131)
+---- Thread: How long can we make that last? (/showthread.php?tid=16045)
How long can we make that last? - Arthur Pettigrew - September 20, 2024
September 20th, 1894, around 10am — Emrys' Residence, Bristol
Arthur apparated from his South Bartonburg garden to the walkway of Emrys' house. His palms were sweaty in his coat pockets. He'd never woken up to an owl on his windowsill from Emrys before; it was lucky that he'd woken up before the sun, and found the letter before Desdemona could see it. He'd spent most of the morning walking around the house until he received Emrys' reply, and left just after the owl, once he'd trimmed his beard to be appropriately roguish.
His knee twinged when he landed on the cobblestones. Art winced, then walked up to the door — he didn't bother knocking, because who else would visit Emrys like this?
"Emrys?" he called. He wiped his hands on his coat.
RE: How long can we make that last? - Emrys Selwyn - September 20, 2024
Emrys hadn't slept well. He'd gotten up multiple times to check whether the sound he heard while tossing and turning was a return owl. He'd given up on his bed around sunrise and relocated to the downstairs parlor, where he'd been stretched out on the couch contemplating all the various things he could do to distract himself. He didn't want to drink; he wanted to be sensible enough that he could respond to letters if any arrived. He'd written Arthur; Angelica might write him. He didn't especially want to be sensible enough to think about anything, but unfortunately it seemed impossible to accomplish one without the other.
Eventually he'd ended up ordering just about every breakfast food known the man from the staff before dismissing them for the day, and was now making occasional trips to his dining room to make plates and half-heartedly pick at fruit salads while he longued on the sitting room sofa. Sober, but contemplating a hookah in the corner of the room.
"Here," he called when he heard Arthur come in. He considered adding Alive, but held back; their experience in the sinkhole might not have been in good taste to joke about, and he was too maudlin at the moment to trust his own judgement on it.
"Thank you for coming," he said when Arthur reached the room, waving him towards a couch. He didn't bother getting up from where he was lounging. His voice was calmer than it ought to be; if he was in Arthur's shoes he imagined he would assume he was high. "I'm thinking of leaving my wife, and I was hoping you'd talk me out of it."
He picked up a grape off his plate and eyed it critically.
RE: How long can we make that last? - Arthur Pettigrew - September 20, 2024
Satisfied that his palms were no longer moist, Art followed the sound of Emrys' voice into the parlor. Emrys looked off, in a way that Art usually saw him look in opium dens — although there was no smell of opium in the room. Art took off his coat; he hung it over the back of the indicated couch, and dropped into it. He was still feeling nervous. He placed his palms on his thighs.
He had half-thought that Emrys summoned him here to break things off — it had always seemed like a half-inevitable eventuality. This, though, was a surprise — the last time they had talked about Emrys' now-wife in detail, Emrys had asked Art if he'd ever come out to a woman.
Art leaned against the back of the sofa. "What happened?" he asked; he was trying to sound more confident than he actually was.
RE: How long can we make that last? - Emrys Selwyn - September 20, 2024
He'd been stewing in this long enough that he ought to have an answer ready for such a simple question. What had he been doing for hours? Not deciding how he would describe this chain of events succinctly and meaningfully to Arthur, apparently. He let out a breath and put the grape back down on the plate, which he lowered onto his lap. "We went to a party," he started. "Argued afterwards." This was accurate, but it seemed so ancillary to what was actually bothering him that saying it at all seemed like a waste of breath. He inhaled and looked down at the plate, trying to think of what to actually say.
It was that she insisted on knowing him, in a way he had not wanted to be known; it was that she never left well enough alone, that she pushed until something broke and called that progress. It was all the assumptions she made about him, all the ways he recognized she didn't really know him at all. She would say that was his fault; she was partially right. It was that she was looking for solutions in all the wrong places. It was that they wanted fundamentally different things from their relationship. It was that he couldn't even look back at that first summer, when they'd been deeply passionate about each other, in the same light now. He couldn't say with confidence that they ever had been on the same page about anything — not after the baby that never came.
There was too much to say, but there was one thing particularly that Emrys felt he was obligated to say; a confession that he owed Arthur. He exhaled. "About you, amongst other things."
RE: How long can we make that last? - Arthur Pettigrew - September 20, 2024
Parties, arguing — none of this seemed eventful enough to require leaving the wife. Art was about to say as much, but then — heat spread across Art's face. He swallowed.
"Does she know who I am?" he asked, the first question that had come to him. If she did — well, he was still willing to try to help Emrys, but he would have a lot of other problems to try to handle first.
RE: How long can we make that last? - Emrys Selwyn - September 20, 2024
"No," he answered, and looked up to meet Arthur's eyes as he did. He didn't particularly want to be looking at Art — he was feeling mortified on an atomic level — but he understood the gravity of a question like this, understood the stakes. He knew it was important for the answer to come immediately and to feel certain. The other man would only be half-listening to him until he was sure of this point — not a fault, just a fact.
He shifted his eyes back down to the couch, around where his feet were resting, and exhaled. "She didn't ask any specifics. But she'd guessed you existed. Sensed your shadow. Your indent in the mattress. The empty space in my suitcase for your souvenirs." This was all metaphor, Emrys indulging himself in his melancholy; in reality she hadn't needed to be a detective to figure it out, he supposed. One admission years ago that she'd hung on to, and the vindictiveness to ask a well-targeted question. He took another heavy breath. "She knew there was someone I loved." He still wasn't looking at Arthur, not yet — this was another admission he didn't want to make but felt the other man was owed, after last night. After taking a second to steel himself he looked back up. "Ridiculous, isn't it? That she said it before I did."
RE: How long can we make that last? - Arthur Pettigrew - September 20, 2024
She didn't know who he was. Arthur exhaled; there would be no scandal about this, no loss of Desdemona and Gwenog. The relief was so overwhelming that he missed the inherent romance in Emrys' words, until his lover's words hit him like a punch to the gut. Art looked at Emrys' eyes, his own eyebrows raised, mouth gone dry.
They both knew it, didn't they? Neither had ever said it. Art certainly hadn't, because it meant reckoning with something: what kind of person was in love with two people at once?
"Not ridiculous," he said, quiet in the silence of the parlor. "She said it before me, too, didn't she?"
RE: How long can we make that last? - Emrys Selwyn - September 20, 2024
He had been sketching out how this confession might be received for hours, but he had not allowed himself to hope for this. He smiled, but not the sort of wide, unburdened smile that accompanied these sorts of declarations when they were made by the young and foolish. His smile was wry; an acknowledgement of their shared tragedy rather than a signal of joy. Aren't we pitiful? this smile said.
"I was going to give you a chance to leave," he said ruefully. He might still want to, in the end; there were things at stake, and Angelica knowing anything about him at all imposed a serious risk, however he felt about Emrys. Sentiment rarely won the day, in situations like this.
RE: How long can we make that last? - Arthur Pettigrew - September 20, 2024
Art should cut and run, and there was a rueful half-smile on his face as he looked at Emrys — they both knew he should go and pretend this never happened. He should let the indent in Emrys' mattress be filled by someone else, let the suitcase space subside, stop planning when to wear a cologne Emrys had bought him in case he would see the other man. He had a family to think about.
His knee, the one that had shattered in the Quidditch World Cup and in the pit, twinged. Art knew that, sooner than he would like, his life was going to change more irrevocably than it had in years. And he — wanted to have Emrys there, for it.
"I can't say I'll never leave," he said, "But I'm not leaving today."
RE: How long can we make that last? - Emrys Selwyn - September 20, 2024
That was as much as he could ask for — more, really. He'd been preparing to open the door and let Arthur leave without a fight; he knew it would have been the smarter thing to do. Having this moment was more than either of them were entitled to. He moved the plate from his lap to the end table and sat up on the couch, shifting his position until he could lean in to kiss Arthur. Three years, and some change. It had started like anything else; haphazard meetups, cryptic letters. Emrys didn't know exactly when it had transitioned into something else, but it was undeniable now. He may have offered Angelica the answer last night because he told himself it was pointless to argue, and an answer was the fastest way through the conversation... but as he'd turned it over after she left he hadn't come up with a way to talk himself out of it. He remembered how he'd clung to Arthur when they were both broken and bruised in the sinkhole; realized the simmering anger from last night when Angelica turned the conversation this direction hadn't just been for his own sake. He wrestled with the very real possibility of saying goodbye, of losing him. There was nothing to attribute this degree of pain to except love.
RE: How long can we make that last? - Arthur Pettigrew - September 20, 2024
He was supposed to be talking Emrys out of leaving his wife. But Art was still feeling the rush of the emotions from the past few minutes. He turned to fully face Emrys and grabbed onto the other man's lapels, and followed Emrys' kiss up with another, hungry one.
RE: How long can we make that last? - Emrys Selwyn - September 20, 2024
What if this was all they did today, Emrys thought with a giddy rush as Arthur pulled on his lapel. What if they just had a moment and then spent the rest of the time he had basking in each other's presence? What if there was nothing else that needed discussing, nothing else to weigh on his mind? Just this?
That wasn't the case, of course.
Several minutes later — when he'd been kissing Arthur long enough that he either needed to stop or escalate — he pulled away with a satisfied sigh.
"Do you want breakfast?" he asked, brighter than he had been so far today.
RE: How long can we make that last? - Arthur Pettigrew - September 21, 2024
Art wished they could have remained kissing for most of the morning; it would be pleasant to do so, and to ignore their various marital problems. Art was sure there was more they had to talk about, with regard to Mrs. Angelica Selwyn. They had not even gotten to Emrys' desire to leave her.
He smiled gently at Emrys when the other man pulled back. "I could eat something," Art said. He could always eat something — he was still a professional athlete and was more or less hungry all of the time.
Now that he knew he wasn't getting left, he was — relieved. They could take the rest of this interlude as quickly or as slowly as they needed to.
RE: How long can we make that last? - Emrys Selwyn - September 21, 2024
Emrys smiled, gently, and leaned in to brush other kiss against his lips. He lead the way to the dining room, where the table was laid out with a veritable buffet — far more food than one person could eat. "I didn't want them back today," he explained, slightly sheepish. "And I wasn't hungry then. So I just asked for everything." He slid around the table and took a seat, leaning one elbow on the table's edge and resting his chin in his palm. He was watching Arthur, observing him — as if he were different now, in the context of this morning, and Emrys needed to learn him from scratch.
"I suppose we should decide whether I'm leaving my wife," he said eventually.
RE: How long can we make that last? - Arthur Pettigrew - September 21, 2024
Art started popping whatever items caught his fancy into his mouth; a cube of melon, a slice of orange. He was halfway through a room-temperature piece of bacon when Emrys spoke. Art finished his bacon before replying.
"I know what happened," Art said, tone thoughtful, "But I'm not sure I know why you want to leave her."
He didn't have jealousy attached to Emrys' wife. They were both married, after all — maybe she was jealous of Arthur, but it would be hypocritical of Arthur to feel that way when he was sure he loved both Desdemona and Emrys. The loves had different shapes, maybe — but they were both romantic, and he loved them both.
RE: How long can we make that last? - Emrys Selwyn - September 21, 2024
"No," Emrys agreed. Arthur wouldn't know why; there was so much Emrys had never told him about Angelica, about their marriage. He didn't talk to anyone about it. He tried not to think about most of it — unsuccessfully. It was all there, lurking at the edges of his mind, making superficial intrusions into anything he was thinking about.
So he would have to explain it, if he wanted Arthur to understand. He knew this, accepted it — (although Arthur never asked; was that why it was so much easier to tell him things than it was with Angelica? There was the unspoken underlying message, with Art: if you want to. When you're ready. Never a demand. And Arthur had never misunderstood him so completely as she had) — but that didn't mean he knew how to begin. He turned the matter over like the Gordian Knot, looking for an end, somewhere it was even possible to start.
"She's — consuming. Like a fire. She can't be satisfied with half of someone. Or with most of them. She needs every door open, to understand everything, know everything. Anything less isn't love, to her. She says I'm running away, hiding. She called me heartless," he said, with a helpless shrug. This was a bit sprawling and indefinite, as far as explanations went, but once he'd started talking words just followed each other without his conscious thought. "I just — can't."